In re Netlist, Inc., Appeal Nos. 2025-1286, -1296 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 13, 2026)
In its only precedential patent decision issued last week, the Federal Circuit considered Netlist’s appeal from inter partes review decisions finding all claims of two computer memory patents unpatentable as obvious. At issue on appeal was whether a POSITA would have been motivated to combine the prior art to arrive at the claimed invention, where the asserted combination would undermine the touted benefits of one of the prior art references and render it inoperable for certain purposes. The Federal Circuit affirmed the unpatentability decision, holding that where a POSITA’s motivation is supplied independently of the prior art at issue, it is only the intended purpose of the claimed invention that matters.
Netlist’s related U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and 9,858,215 were directed to improvements in computer memory architecture, in which—among other limitations not germane to the appeal—a memory module that uses “chip select signals” includes “circuitry” that acts as a buffer between memory devices and the memory controller of a computer. The patents explained that the use of such a buffer advantageously isolates ranks of devices within the module, which decreases the load on the system. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board found the challenged claims obvious over a combination of, inter alia, a prior art patent to “Perego”—which disclosed memory module buffer device—and JESD79-2, an industry specification for memory modules using chip select signals in compliance with Joint Electron Device Engineering Council (JEDEC) standards.
As relevant to the appeal, Perego disclosed memory modules for a “Rambus” architecture, which is based on competing specifications from Rambus, Inc. that rely on unique device identifiers instead of the chip-select signals used in JEDEC devices. Netlist argued Perego’s modules were not compatible with the chip-select signal characteristics of a JEDEC architecture, such that the combination with JESD79-2 would have rendered Perego’s modules inoperable in their intended Rambus environment. In its decision, however, the Board found motivation to combine “based on indications in Perego that suggested amenability to JEDEC standards, Perego’s concern with flexibility to accommodate a variety of module configurations, and dominance of JEDEC standards in the marketplace at the relevant time.”
Because Perego’s intended purpose was to improve Rambus architecture, Netlist argued on appeal that the Board erred in finding a motivation to combine. Netlist relied on cases like In re Gordon, 733 F.2d 900 (Fed. Cir. 1984), in which a patent for a blood filter assembly with an inlet and outlet at the “bottom end” was found not obvious in view of a prior art gasoline filter with an inlet and outlet located at the top end. The prior art filter had relied on gravity to separate gasoline from heavier contaminants, and the Court in that case found a POSITA would not be motivated to “invert” the filter to arrive at the claimed invention, which would have rendered the prior art filter inoperable.
In this case, the reviewing panel distinguished Gordon and similar cases, explaining that in such cases, the asserted “motivation to combine” was supplied by the functionality of the prior art itself, such that undermining that functionality would also defeat the POSITA’s motivation for the asserted modification. The Court similarly distinguished cases in which the combination would undermine a “shared purpose” between the prior art and the invention of the challenged claims. The panel explained that absent such facts, it is the purpose of the claimed invention that controls.
Here, the Board had found motivation to combine independently of the teachings of the prior art, including based on the marketplace dominance of JEDEC standards at the time of the invention. Netlist did not argue that Perego taught away from such a combination—indeed, the Board had relied on indications in Perego that it contemplated use with other module configurations. As such, the fact that the asserted combination would render Perego’s modules inoperable for their original intended purpose did not control whether a POSITA would be motivated to modify them to arrive at the claimed invention, i.e. a module compatible with the with the chip-select signals used in prevalent JEDEC devices at the time.
Having found the Board’s determination supported by substantial evidence, the Federal Circuit panel affirmed the unpatentability decision.
The opinion can be found here.
By Jason Wrubleski
Sign up